
January 27, 2025
When to Engage a Professional Electrical Engineer as an Expert Witness
When disputes or litigation arise that involve electrical systems, equipment, or safety, the expertise of a professional electrical engineer can be invaluable.
These specialists bring a wealth of knowledge and practical experience to the table, offer critical insights, explain complex electrical concepts, and can aid stakeholders to shape the outcome of a case. But when exactly should you engage a professional electrical engineer as an expert witness? This blog post delves into the scenarios where their involvement is crucial and how their expertise can make a significant difference. The next post will explore the benefits of engaging an expert witness early and how to choose the right expert witness.
Understanding the Role of an Expert Witness
Expert witnesses are specialists who provide informed opinions and testimony based on their expertise in particular fields. In the context of electrical engineering, these experts analyze complex technical issues, interpret data, and explain their findings in a way that mediators, arbitrators, or judges and juries can understand. They serve as a bridge between the often-intricate world of electrical engineering and the legal system, ensuring that all parties have a clear understanding of the technical aspects of a case. The key responsibilities of an electrical engineering expert are:
- Technical Analysis: Conducting thorough investigations and analyses of electrical systems and incidents.
- Report Preparation: Documenting findings in detailed reports that can be used in court proceedings.
- Testimony: Providing unbiased expert testimony in court, explaining technical concepts and findings in an understandable manner.
- Consultation: Advising legal teams on technical matters and helping to develop case strategies.
When to Engage a Professional Electrical Engineer
Knowing when to bring an electrical engineer on board can be pivotal to the success of your case. Here are some common scenarios where such expertise is essential:
1. Electrical Accidents and Safety Violations
Electrical accidents can lead to severe consequences, including injuries, fatalities, and property damage. In cases involving electrical mishaps, the determination of fault or liability often hinges on technical details. A professional electrical engineer can:
- Analyze the design and installation of electrical systems to determine compliance with safety standards such as the National Electrical Code (NEC) or Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) regulations.
- Investigate the cause of electrical failures and safety incidents, such as short circuits, electrocutions, arc flashes, fires caused by faulty wiring, or ground faults.
- Provide insights into whether proper safety measures and protocols were followed.
By offering detailed assessments and clear explanations, a professional electrical engineer can help clarify whether negligence or improper practices contributed to the incident.
2. Construction Defects and Contract Disputes
Construction projects often involve complex electrical systems that must adhere to precise specifications and standards. When disputes arise over defective work, cost overruns, or delays, an expert witness can provide an impartial evaluation. A professional electrical engineer can:
- Review the project plans to determine their sufficiency for equipment and material supply and installation.
- Examine whether the electrical work met contract requirements, design specifications, and industry standards.
- Assess the quality of materials, installation methods, and overall workmanship.
- Identify deficiencies or non-compliance with building codes.
Their testimony can be crucial in resolving disputes by establishing whether owners, engineers, contractors, subcontractors, or suppliers fulfilled their obligations.
3. Power System Failures and Outages
Power system failures can lead to significant economic losses and operational disruptions. In disputes involving utility companies, municipalities, businesses, or contractors, an electrical engineer can:
- Investigate the causes of power outages, such as equipment malfunctions, inadequate maintenance, or natural events.
- Assess the design and reliability of power distribution systems.
- Evaluate claims related to financial losses or operational downtime.
Professional electrical engineers’ abilities to dissect complex power systems ensure that all relevant factors are considered.
4. Patent Infringement and Intellectual Property Disputes
In cases involving patented electrical technologies, professional electrical engineers serving as expert witnesses play a crucial role in determining whether intellectual property rights have been violated. Professional electrical engineers can:
- Analyze technical details to assess similarities and differences between patented designs and alleged infringements.
- Provide expert opinions on the novelty, functionality, and application of disputed technologies.
- Help the stakeholders and decision makers understand intricate engineering principles related to the case.
This expertise is invaluable in cases where understanding nuanced technical distinctions is essential. Their testimony can be crucial in protecting patents and intellectual property rights.
5. Product Liability Claims
When electrical products such as tools, appliances, or components fail, they can cause injuries, fires, or equipment damage. In product liability cases, determining whether the failure was due to a manufacturing defect, design flaw, or misuse is critical. Professional electrical engineers can:
- Conduct forensic analysis to determine the root cause of the failure.
- Evaluate whether the product was designed and manufactured according to industry standards and met safety criteria of organizations such as UL Solutions and the CSA Group.
- Provide insights into user behavior and whether misuse contributed to the incident.
By leveraging their expertise, professional electrical engineers can offer objective findings that support fair outcomes in these cases.
6. Compliance with Regulations
Electrical systems must comply with numerous regulations and standards set by organizations such as the National Electrical Code (NEC), National Electrical Safety Code (NESC), and Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA). Organizations are often subject to regulatory oversight regarding their electrical systems and operations. When non-compliance with regulations leads to investigations or penalties, professional electrical engineers can:
- Assess whether systems meet legal and regulatory standards.
- Identify potential areas of non-compliance and their implications.
- Provide guidance on corrective actions to prevent future violations.
Their involvement can help resolve disputes while ensuring systems align with applicable laws and standards.
Conclusion
Engaging professional electrical engineers as expert witnesses is essential in disputes involving electrical systems, devices, safety concerns, and compliance issues. Their technical expertise, analytical skills, and ability to communicate complex concepts make them invaluable assets in investigations and litigation. By involving an expert early and choosing the right professional for your case, you can enhance your legal strategy, preserve critical evidence, and ultimately increase the likelihood of a favorable outcome. Whether dealing with accidents, construction disputes, patent cases, power outages, product liability claims, or regulatory compliance, a professional electrical engineer’s insights can illuminate the technical intricacies and support a compelling legal argument.
ADDITIONAL RESOURCES

Blog
Discover industry insights on construction disputes and claims, project management, risk analysis, and more.
MORE

Articles
Articles by our engineering and construction claims experts cover topics ranging from acceleration to why claims occur.
MORE

Publications
We are committed to sharing industry knowledge through publication of our books and presentations.
MORE
RECOMMENDED READS
The Role and Benefit of a Consultant in a Construction Project: Part 1
This is the first blog post in a two-part series on the role and benefit of a construction consultant.
READ
The Benefits of Consultants for Construction Projects
This is the second blog post in a two-part series on the role and benefit of a construction consultant.
READ
The Role and Benefit of a Construction Insurance Claims Advisor
This blog post outlines how construction insurance claims advisors can assist insurance companies and insured project owners.
READ